Wednesday, September 28, 2011

CBS Fall Pilot Review: How to Be a Gentleman - Premieres September 29; TeenNick Adds Hey Dude,The Amanda Show, More To The '90s Are All That Block

How to Be a Gentleman

How to Be a Gentleman - Thursdays 8:30PM ET/PT on CBS
Premieres Thursday, September 29, 2011 at 8:30PM ET/PT


Columnist Andrew Carlson (David Hornsby) thinks that he is the "perfect gentleman" in How to Be a Gentleman, but when the publication that he is working for undergoes some significant demographic changes, he either has to change his views or face unemployment. His problem? While he knows how to be a perfect gentleman, he doesn't know how to be the perfect man. He's always been the guy to hold doors open for women and to keep his areas clean and tidy, but he has also been the kid who was constantly bullied when he was younger.

The changes at his magazine, which require Andrew to change his column, are only the beginning of the changes for Andrew's life. While seeking out ways to reinvent his column, Andrew runs into former high school bully Bert Lansing (Kevin Dillon), who now runs a gym. The meeting with Bert gives Andrew a chance to begin reassessing everything that he may be able to write for his column, and further gives him an opportunity to reassess his life, and what it truly means to be a gentleman.

Cast Details:

• David Hornsby as Andrew Carlson
• Kevin Dillon as Bert Lansing
• Dave Foley as Jerry
• Mary Lynn Rajskub as Janet
• Rhys Darby as Mike

David Hornsby (Andrew) is the star of the series, the columnist who writes about "how to be a perfect gentleman." He has appeared in It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, The Joe Schmo Show, and Six Feet Under. In addition to his role in the series, he is also the creator of the series.

Kevin Dillon (Bert) plays the guy who is going to teach Andrew how to be a man in the series. If the last name sounds familiar, it should: he is the younger brother of actor Matt Dillon. But Kevin Dillon has also had success of his own, playing the role of Drama in the recently ended HBO series Entourage, as well as roles in movies such as Platoon.

Dave Foley (Jerry) plays Andrew's boss at the magazine, a boss who is resistant to the changes, but is too close to retirement to fight them. Canadian-born Foley played the starring role of Dave Nelson in the 90s NBC series NewsRadio, and has had countless guest-starring roles in series such as The New Adventures of Old Christine, Will & Grace, Brothers & Sisters, and many more.

Mary Jane Rajskub (Janet) plays the role of Andrew's sister in the series. Rajskub is well-known for her starring role as Chloe O'Brien on the series 24. She has also had roles in The Larry Sanders Show, NewsRadio, and Veronica's Closet. Additionally, she was one of the original cast members of Mr. Show.

Rhys Darby (Mike) plays Janet's husband and Andrew's quirky brother-in-law. The New Zealand born actor is best known to viewers in the United States as Murray from the HBO series Flight of the Conchords.


Pilot Plot:

In the pilot episode, we are introduced to Andrew Carlson, the author of a magazine column about how to be a perfect gentleman. We see how he is the perfect Mr. Manners. But this all comes crashing down during a meeting with his boss Jerry, who informs Andrew that changes are about to come to the magazine. A new owner of the magazine doesn't see profits in the magazine as it is, and wants to retool the magazine to a more hip and edgier magazine for modern men.

During an incredibly depressing birthday dinner with his sister and brother-in-law, where Andrew recounts all of his failures in life and his disdain over the new changes, Andrew receives a gift of a training session at a gym. Andrew doesn't really like this gift, but a perfect gentleman always uses a gift, whether he likes it or not. When he goes to the gym, he runs in to Bert. Bert used to bully Andrew in high school, but this encounter begins a new relationship between the two when Andrew begins to use Bert's wisdom to help him adapt to the changes in the magazine, as well as his life in general.

Analysis:

Can anybody say Felix Unger and Oscar Madison forty years later? I think that is a fair assessment of what this series is, and this series takes on a lot of the classic series The Odd Couple. Now sometimes, imitation is bad, but in this series, it seems to be rather well executed, and unlike many pilots out there, this puts a fresh perspective on an old idea.

There weren't really that many moments in the pilot that I disliked, and unlike many pilots that I have seen, the action seemed to move pretty fast in the pilot. It seems that many pilots are very slow to develop the main plot of the series, and get annoying by the end of the first episode, often setting a bad tone for the entire series. This one didn't.

As for the comedy of the series, it seemed a bit subdued in the pilot, but that isn't to say that the series is unfunny. A series like this one, on how to be manly, is a perfect setup for some good comedy. The pilot didn't fully take advantage of those capabilities, but I'm hoping that as the series goes on, it will take advantage of them a bit more. Luckily, though, the pilot seemed to be well-written, and good writing can often make up for other areas that may be lacking.

My only criticism of the series is the casting of Kevin Dillon in the role of Bert. That isn't to say that I dislike Kevin Dillon. In fact, I like his acting, and enjoyed him in Entourage. But to me, he seems (and I'll add, is) too old to be playing one of Andrew's classmates from high school. He is about ten years older than Hornsby, and at least in my opinion, the difference really was evident. However, with the series set to air already, this is, lamentably, something that is going to have to remain as is, and despite that age difference, he does well in the role--he just isn't the right person.


Conclusion:

I actually liked the pilot of the series, and I'm hopeful that this could be a great series to add to my weekly viewing schedule. Even though it really is just a modern-day take on The Odd Couple (and I think you'll see that in the first few seconds of the series), it brings that type of show to the modern era. I feel like the odds are against this series from the beginning, as CBS still hasn't established a level of success for the 8:30 Thursday slot, even though they were able to transfer viewers of The Big Bang Theory to the Thursday night slot. But maybe this series will work in the slot after The Big Bang Theory, as viewers will be able to relate the character of Andrew to some on The Big Bang Theory. I hope that this series at least goes for a full season, and perhaps longer. It has potential that I rarely see in new sitcoms these days.

Final Numbers (out of 5 stars):

Watchability: 4/5
Funniness: 3/5
Overall: 3.5/5

-- Reviewed by skees53 on 09/28/11

Discuss the show after you watch it on Thursday, September 29 on our message board.

Related Links:

  • CBS.com Official Site
  • TV.com
  • epguides.com
  • Internet Movie Database
  • Wikipedia
  • How to Be a Gentleman Photo Gallery

    Preview:





    Effective this week, Doug and Clarissa Explains It All returned to The '90s Are All That block on TeenNick, but that's not all! More shows are coming. For now, Rocko's Modern Life and Hey Arnold! are off the line-up after three weeks, but they could return at some point. All That and Kenan & Kel are still scheduled to stay on the air to kick off the weeknight late night block in the 12-1am hour (encores 2-3am). Onto the new series, replacing Clarissa Explains It starting next week (Monday, Oct. 3), will be Hey Dude! The early '90s comedic western will air at 1am with an encore at 3am. As of now, it is scheduled for two weeks. Then starting October 17, the half-hour will be the Amanda Bynes series The Amanda Show. Then starting Oct. 31, just in time for Halloween it is Are You Afraid of the Dark? at 1am and 3am! It looks like a rotating wheel of classic Nick series is airing in this timeslot. Doug is remaining put in the 1:30am half-hour.
    That's not all! Fridays starting next week (Oct. 7) will see the return of someone familiar. Stick Stickly! Every Friday night will now be: "The 90s Are All That! U Pick with Stick." Yes, Stick Stickly returns to host a special viewer's choice night of The '90s Are All That with options for some rarely seen Nick gems. There are eight choices for the first week: 1. Clarissa Explains It All: The "Normal" Episode, 2. My Brother and Me: Dee Dee Can't Dance, 3. Aaahh!!! Real Monsters: The Snorch Episode, 4. Salute Your Shorts: The Bunk Chief Episode, 5. Rugrats: The Chocolate Milk Football Episode, 6. The First Angry Beavers' Episode, 7. Legends Of The Hidden Temple: The Talking Rock and 8. Doug's Golden Toe Episode.
    Vote for your favorite on the official website! It's a two-hour block, so I think four of these eight will air. This is a nice way to air the rarely seen classics! Friday nights just got better!

  • Sitcoms Airing Tonight / Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows

    Sunday, November 22

    Animal Control - "Tortoises and Billy Goats" (Fox, 7:00PM ET/PT) (Repeat)
    When Emily's HR review threatens her reinstatement, Frank appoints himself her investigator.

    Grimsburg - "Flutey Friday" (Fox, 7:30PM ET/PT) (Repeat)
    Flute and Stan switch bodies for a day.

    The Simpsons - "Curb Your Expectations" (Fox, 8:00PM ET/PT)
    After Krusty's latest marriage ends in spectacular fashion, he swears off love forever, only to discover his perfect match in a familiar face.

    Animal Control - "Boas and Spiders" (Fox, 8:30PM ET/PT)
    Frank takes over as interim boss while Emily heads into the field to assist an elderly woman; a boa constrictor gets loose during a group of schoolchildren's visit to the precinct.

    Universal Basic Guys - "Male Pattern Wellness" (Fox, 9:00PM ET/PT)
    Mark inserts himself into DelVecchio's wellness retreat; Hugh forces Hank to confront his hot dog habit.

    Grimsburg - "Fur Force" (Fox, 9:30PM ET/PT)
    A government-funded team of talking dogs infiltrates the Grimsburg PD.

    Complete TV Listings


    Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows (Week of November 16)

    Friday, November 20

    • Arnold Schwarzenegger (FUBAR) - Watch Arnold on a repeat of Jimmy Kimmel Live! at 11:35pm on ABC.
    • Timothy Olyphant (Stick/Santa Clarita Diet) and Owen Wilson (Stick) - Timothy and Owen are guests on a repeat of Late Night with Seth Meyers at 12:36am on NBC.
    • Carla Gugino (Californication/Entourage/Spin City) - Carla talks about The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth on NBC's Today in the 9am hour.
    • Vivica A. Fox (Mr. Box Office/Getting Personal/Arsenio/Out All Night) - Vivica talks about Checking Inn for Christmas on NBC's Today in the 10am hour.
    • Walton Goggins (The Righteous Gemstones/The Unicorn/Vice Principals) - Walton talks about Hexed on ABC's Good Morning America sometime betwen 7-9am.
    • Wilmer Valderrama (That '70s Show) - Wilmer drops by the studio to talk about NCIS on Live with Kelly and Mark, so check your local listings.
    • Liv Hewson (Santa Clarita Diet) - Drew sits down with Liv to talk all about the fourth and final season of the hit show Yellowjackets on The Drew Barrymore Show, so check your local listings. She can also be heard on the Morning Mash Up on SiriusXM.
    • Melanie Lynskey (Two and a Half Men/Togetherness) - Melanie can be heard on the Morning Mash Up on SiriusXM.


    New on DVD and Blu-ray

    Perfect Strangers - The Complete Series (Blu-ray) Happy's Place - Season Two (Blu-ray) Abbott Elementary - The Complete Fifth Season (DVD) Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage - The Complete Second Season (DVD) Superstore - The Complete Series (Blu-ray)

    08/25/26 - Perfect Strangers - The Complete Series (Blu-ray) (DVD)
    09/08/26 - Looney Tunes Collector's Vault - Volume 3 (Blu-ray)
    09/22/26 - Bridget Loves Bernie - The Complete Series (Blu-ray)
    09/29/26 - Happy's Place - Season Two (Blu-ray) (DVD)
    10/20/26 - Abbott Elementary - The Complete Fifth Season (DVD)
    10/20/26 - The Brady Bunch - The Complete Original Series (2026 Release) (DVD)
    10/20/26 - The Quick Draw McGraw Show - The Complete Series (Blu-ray)
    10/20/26 - Shrinking - The Complete First and Second Seasons (DVD)
    10/20/26 - South Park - The Complete Twenty-Seventh and Twenty-Eighth Seasons (DVD)
    11/03/26 - Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage - The Complete Second Season (DVD)
    11/03/26 - Rick and Morty - The Complete Ninth Season (Blu-ray) (DVD)
    11/03/26 - SpongeBob SquarePants - The Complete Sixteenth Season (DVD)
    11/03/26 - Superstore - The Complete Series (Blu-ray)
    11/24/26 - The Yogi Bear Show - The Complete Series (Blu-ray)

    More Recent and Upcoming TV DVD and Blu-ray Releases / TV Shows on DVD, Blu-ray and Prime Video / DVD Reviews Archive


    Recent SitcomsOnline.com News Blog Posts

    11/21 - SitcomsOnline Digest: NBC Prepares for 100th Anniversary; First Trailer for Ted: The Animated Series
    11/20 - Tubi Heads to The Airport for Comedy Series; Netflix Orders Animated Series Grendel
    11/19 - The CW Midseason 2027 Premiere Dates; Great Entertainment Television's Thanksgiving Week Marathons
    11/18 - CBS Midseason 2027 Premiere Dates; Wonder Project Gets a Sitcom
    11/17 - Pluto TV to Add 5 Classic Series; Family Guy Hulu Holiday Special Trailer and Key Art
    11/16 - Apple TV's She's Fine Starring Elizabeth Banks Premieres January 27; Netflix's Virgin River Renewed for Season 9
    11/15 - Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows; This Week in Sitcoms (Week of November 16, 2026)
    11/14 - SitcomsOnline Digest: Adults Renewed for Third Season; First Look and Premiere Date for Sunset P.I.
    11/13 - CBS Special I Love Lucy: 75 Years of Laughter; Remembering Stacy Keach of Titus and Anthony Clark of Yes, Dear
    11/12 - Fox Winter 2027 Premiere Dates; FX Renews Adults for Season 3
    11/11 - Rewind TV's The Hogan Family 40th Anniversary Marathon; Prime Video's Overcompensating Season 2 Details
    11/10 - Antenna TV's Thanksgiving on the Eastside: The Jeffersons Marathon; Laverne & Shirley Book Released in Celebration of the Sitcom's 50th Anniversary
    11/09 - ABC Midseason 2027 Schedule; Netflix Renews Nobody Wants This for Season 4
    11/08 - Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows; This Week in Sitcoms (Week of November 9, 2026)
    11/07 - SitcomsOnline Digest: Nobody Wants This Renewed at Netflix; Grey's Anatomy Spinoff to Be Filmed in New Mexico
    11/06 - NBC's New Rockford Files Premieres January 2; Bobby Lee: Finally Drops November 27 on Hulu
    11/05 - Three's Company 50th Anniversary NYC Event Recap; Disney+ Reveals Details for A Proud Family Wizmas
    11/04 - Mickey's Home Alone on Disney Jr. and Disney+; Pretty Little Liars Duo Reunite for Hulu Christmas Film
    11/03 - Freeform's 25 Days of Christmas 2026 Schedule; HBO Renews Youth for Season 2
    11/02 - Details on Only Murders Season 6; Haunted Hotel Renewed for Season 3
    11/01 - Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows; This Week in Sitcoms (Week of November 2, 2026)
    10/31 - SitcomsOnline Digest: Criminal Minds Coming to an End; Baywatch Premiere Date Set
    10/30 - VH1 to Bring Back America's Funniest People Starring Ms. Pat; Remembering Barbara Barrie and Patrick Stewart
    10/29 - Peacock's Dig Trailer and Artwork; The CW 2026 Holiday Programming with A Very Brady Christmas, A Flintstone Christmas and More
    10/28 - ABC 2026 Holiday Programming; Remembering Susan Saint James of Kate & Allie
    10/27 - Fox's Baywatch Premieres January 6; aspireTV's First Sitcom Premieres January 7
    10/26 - COZI TV's Halloween Schedule with Roseanne, George Lopez, The Munsters and More; Chloe Radcliffe: Eyes Down Here Stand-up Special
    10/25 - Sitcom Stars on Talk Shows; This Week in Sitcoms (Week of October 26, 2026)
    10/24 - SitcomsOnline Digest: Reboots in the Works for Coach and Glee; Saturday Night Live Sets November Hosts
    10/23 - Prime Video Renews Carrie for Season 2; Remembering Richard Riehle of Grounded for Life
    10/22 - Abbott Elementary Returns Big After 7 Day Viewing; BET Renews ComicView: Rooftop Series
    10/21 - Charmed Joining Hulu This Huluween; Prime Video's Comedy Variety Series Hosted by Nick Kroll